Your tremendous work has resulted in the dismantling of an organized crime family responsible for numerous murders and other crimes.
— U.S. Attorney's Office Award citation, EDNY (June, 2018)
Federal agents in New York pulled off the biggest one-day Mafia roundup in United States history yesterday, simultaneously bringing the hammer down on more than 120 reputed wiseguys — a takedown so enormous it required a Brooklyn Army fort to book them all.
— New York Post
The lead agent in the Colombo purge.
— Huffington Post contract columnist Jerry Capeci (2011)
Pay-to-play was the order of the day in Allentown and in Reading. [Curtis’s] years-long investigation illuminated troubling conduct for which all of those indicted must now answer.
— Michael Harpster, Special Agent in Charge, FBI/Philadelphia
The one thing Scott said that is very important, Scott mentioned [the feeling out there] that the FBI had gotten too political.
— Geraldo Rivera on CNN NewsNight with Abby Phillip
Special Agent Curtis’s cultivation of Cooperating Witnesses has accounted for the majority of current Colombo intelligence.
— FBI performance review (2008)
Hardest hit by the raid was the Colombo family, considered to be one of the mob’s bloodiest outfits. West Point grad Scott Curtis had presented [the informant] with his options: Go back to prison for the rest of your life or come work for Team America.
— Men's Journal
Relentless.
— Benton Campbell, U.S. Attorney, Eastern District of New York
Scott Curtis was a scourge of the Colombos, participating in the arrests of more than 100 gangsters, convincing at least a dozen wiseguys to reject their Mafia oath and become government informants.
— New York Daily News
This largest single-day operation against La Cosa Nostra sends the message that our fight against traditional organized crime is strong, and our commitment is unwavering.
— Press conference, United States Attorney General Eric Holder

The record 2011 takedown (requiring Curtis run point for months, working hand in hand with the EDNY U.S. Attorneys’ office) made headlines internationally. Curtis rendered all key tactical and operational decisions as the guy actually out in the field working informants and flipping new ones, too, including on the very day of the bust. The Allentown Morning Call has cited Curtis’s resulting “semi-celebrity status” in New York City.

What began as Curtis’s investigation of this single murderous Colombo cell was designated by Eastern District of New York (EDNY) attorneys several months prior to the mass arrest as the tip of the spear, the testimony of his cooperators alone implicating dozens of organized-crime members in felonious offenses across all five New York Italian-mafia families and New Jersey’s DeCavalcante family (inspiration for The Sopranos).

United States Attorney General Eric Holder was on hand the day of the mega-bust at EDNY offices, introduced to Curtis by the attorneys he had worked with so closely, Holder personally congratulating Curtis for this historic achievement. FBI Colombo-squad supervisor Seamus McElearney emailed Curtis three days later: “You did an unbelievable job putting this all together—great determination.”

“What I really can’t comprehend….[is why the FBI] won’t rein in FBI Agent Scott Curtis,” a one-time acting boss of the Colombo crime family named Tommy Gioeli famously complained to the world in 2011 on his media-savvy personal blog—before being tried and finally sentenced to 18 years in a federal jail. Curtis also busted brokerage-boiler rooms hijacked by the mob that defrauded thousands of regular folks of more than $40 million. Flipping violent criminals into cooperating witnesses, Curtis has an ultra-rare, intimate familiarity with the witness-protection program. 

William "Wild Bill" Cutolo and where his killers buried him and Scott Curtis located him 9 years later.

Colombo underboss William “Wild Bill” Cutolo—and where ex-FBI agent Scott Curtis found him 9 years after he went missing.

The newer generation of mobsters who were raised in the suburbs is accused by its elders of being too soft, stupid, and obsessed with phones, according to a Wall Street Journal interview with Scott Curtis.

IN THE MEDIA

May 26, 2011 letter to FBI director Robert Mueller from the Laborers’ Intl. Union of North America (LIUNA) Inspector General crediting Scott Curtis for the record January 11, 2011 mafia-member takedown dismantling the Colombos’ ruling hierarchy—for a spell, anyway.

Curtis has also weighed in multiply on Bryan Kohberger, the 28-year-old former criminology PhD student who finally pled guilty to having committed a quadruple murder at the University of Idaho and whose DNA was linked to the crime scene.

"I was surprised that he pled guilty or decided to plead guilty as the prosecutor was outlining the facts of the case and the evidence of the case. It didn't seem like such a slam dunk case there and there was room for doubt, reasonable doubt that the defendant could take advantage of," Curtis noted.

"Obviously there was evidence linking him to the crime scene and there were events that took place before and afterwards that circumstantially could add to the prosecutors' case there proving that he was the only one with the means and the only one that was available in that vicinity at that time that could perpetrate those murders but we have no eyewitness to those murders actually taking place." 

Curtis also found Kohberger's body language in court telling.

"I've dealt with cold-blooded killers who went to court and plead guilty to their involvement in murders and who broke down crying and showed a lot of emotion in that process but I also had cold-blooded killers who were involved in murders who stood up in court like Kohberger and just rattled off 'yes I'm guilty' to a bunch of murders showing no emotion and appearing to show no remorse for what he had done at all," Curtis observed.  

"They're sociopaths or psychopaths and they probably showed from an early part of their lives going back to childhood that they would show no emotion toward any type of hardship or people being hurt. They're basically callous to things that regular people would say I feel bad about that."

"Everybody would love to know what that answer is, why this happened, why he did these crimes," said Curtis on the eve of sentencing, admitting some late-in-the-game admissions were unlikely: "I don't think Kohberger is going to say anything. I don't think the judge is going to force him to say anything."

“A square shooter.”

Defense Attorney Eric Dowdle describing Curtis in the Allentown Morning Call / Read Full Article 

“This Scott Curtis is all over the place!”

— Covert recording, Colombo crime-family captain


One way the New York and Allentown cases diverge is Curtis’s semi-celebrity status in New York. In the city’s courtrooms and in the pages of its local tabloid newspapers, he was mentioned almost as often as the men and women he was investigating.
— Allentown Morning Call